Belanjawan 2020

[Mad_Hatter]

You are the most respected member of CG. Dont provoke people with your dirty agenda. PH contribute more to the chinese as most of the chinese voted PH.
Malays skool also received their fund. Stop complaining, start participating.

Komunis mesti support komunis. Betul tak. Lain-lain tu alasan je...

 

[BenVentures]

Komunis mesti support komunis. Betul tak. Lain-lain tu alasan je...

What about the RM6.6 billion given to Mara, UiTM and Yayasan Peneraju for education? When you add the allocations for MRSM, boarding schools, government aided religious schools, tahfiz schools, people and private religious schools, registered pondok religious schools etc.and given the fact that most national and national type schools are majority Malays/Muslims, then the Malays/Muslims have received allocations way beyond their 50.2% of the population excluding the natives of Sabah and Sarawak.

 

[BenVentures]

Sekolah kebangsaan dilayan secara tidak adil, kata Ismail Sabri

Diterbitkan Hari ini 6:41 petang | Dikemaskini Hari ini 6:43 petang


PARLIMEN l Ketua Pembangkang Dewan Rakyat, Ismail Sabri Yaakob menuduh kerajaan Pakatan Harapan tidak memberi layanan yang adil kepada sekolah kebangsaan dalam Belanjawan 2020.

Membandingkan, peruntukan RM300 juta kepada 9,000 sekolah kebangsaan dengan RM15 juta untuk diserahkan kepada 60 buah sekolah menengah persendirian Cina, katanya, setiap sekolah Cina itu akan mendapat purata RM250,000 pada tahun 2020.

Jumlah itu, menurutnya, adalah 6.5 kali atau 555 peratus lebih tinggi daripada RM38,172 yang akan diterima oleh setiap sekolah rendah kebangsaan.

“Dan sekiranya pengagihan peruntukan ini dihitung berdasarkan bilangan kelas, 1 kelas sekolah kebangsaan mendapat hanya sebanyak RM1,986 peruntukan naik taraf.

“Sedangkan 1 kelas SJKC mendapat sebanyak RM2,602 dan SJKT mendapat sebanyak RM11,299,” katanya semasa perbahasan Belanjawan 2020 di Dewan Rakyat.

Justeru, kata pemimpin Umno itu, pembahagian peruntukan kewangan perlu dilaksanakan secara lebih adil dan berpadanan haruslah berpandukan bilangan sekolah dan jumlah pelajar.

“Bukannya sekadar bersifat pukul rata...

“Kalau konsep kesamarataan itu digunakan, tentu sekolah kebangsaam dapat banyak, sekarang dasar tidak sama rataan dilaksanakan, dasar tidak adil dilaksanakan,” katanya.

Sementara itu, Shahidan Kassim (BN-Arau) mencelah dan berkata bahawa belanjawan untuk pendidikan harus diperuntukkan mengikut komposisi kaum di negara ini.

“Jumlah penduduk negara ini, bumiputera 70 peratus, 22.8 peratus Cina, 6.9 peratus India.

Apa asas digunakan untuk beri bantuan pendidikan, mengapa tidak ikut asas penduduk,” soalnya.

Sekolah kebangsaan dilayan secara tidak adil, kata Ismail Sabri

PARLIMEN l Ketua pembakang itu mempersoalkan asas yang digunakan dalam mengagihkan peruntukan kewangan kepada sekolah-sekolah di negara ini.

www.malaysiakini.com

Not sure if the figures are correct. But if they are, he is comparing rambutans with durians when he mentioned that the amount an independent HIGH school receives is about 6 times more than a national PRIMARY school. Why is he not comparing what an independent HIGH school gets with a national SECONDARY school? Another thing. Is there a typo in this report that an Indian primary school receives RM11,299? I doubt this figure is correct. But If it is correct, it may be because Indian primary schools have been in neglect by the pre-2018 government and are now in need of more money to catch up. The budget should reflect the current needs of the different types of schools.

 

[Mad_Hatter]

What about the RM6.6 billion given to Mara, UiTM and Yayasan Peneraju for education? When you add the allocations for MRSM, boarding schools, government aided religious schools, tahfiz schools, people and private religious schools, registered pondok religious schools etc.and given the fact that most national and national type schools are majority Malays/Muslims, then the Malays/Muslims have received allocations way beyond their 50.2% of the population excluding the natives of Sabah and Sarawak.

Nampak je banyak, bila kira per kepala sikit je.

 

[BenVentures]

The fund was distributed based on needs, not based on racial profile. If the chinese skool admins make proper and detail paperwork for more fund, why not?
Stop picking on this issue.

Moderator shud close and delete this thread. Case closed. Move on

 

[Mad_Hatter]

Not sure if the figures are correct. But if they are, he is comparing rambutans with durians when he mentioned that the amount an independent HIGH school receives is about 6 times more than a national PRIMARY school. Why is he not comparing what an independent HIGH school gets with a national SECONDARY school? Another thing. Is there a typo in this report that an Indian primary school receives RM11,299? I doubt this figure is correct. But If it is correct, it may be because Indian primary schools have been in neglect by the pre-2018 government and are now in need of more money to catch up. The budget should reflect the current needs of the different types of schools.

Betul dah tu, ko je yang tak reti kira

 

[Mad_Hatter]

The fund was distributed based on needs, not based on racial profile. If the chinese skool admins make proper and detail paperwork for more fund, why not?
Stop picking on this issue.

Moderator shud close and delete this threaf. Case closed. Move on

Standard perangai komunis, semua orang kena ikut cakap ko je .
Kalau dalam cg dah camni perangai, apa lagi bila jadi MP.

 

[BenVentures]

Nampak je banyak, bila kira per kepala sikit je.

Almost 90% of the budget is bumiputera centric as most of the budget is to pay salaries and supplies incurred by civil service , majority is bumi

so when calculating by race, dont just take allocation on individual basis

use the entire budget and then allocate who gets what

 

[Mad_Hatter]

Almost 90% of the budget is bumiputera centric as most of the budget is to pay salaries and supplies incurred by civil service , majority is bumi

so when calculating by race, dont just take allocation on individual basis

use the entire budget and then allocate who gets what

Tapi orang cerita sekolah SWASTA Cina vs sekolah tak swasta kerajaan. Lu cerita keseluruhan bajet watpe.

 

[BenVentures]

Tapi orang cerita sekolah SWASTA Cina vs sekolah tak swasta kerajaan. Lu cerita keseluruhan bajet watpe.

Can ask Pas for extra 90 million.